How Much Do Early Teachers Matter?
We present new estimates of the importance of teachers in early grades for later grade outcomes, but unlike the existing literature that examines teacher “fade-out,” we directly compare the contribution of early-grade teachers to later year outcomes against the contributions of later year teachers to the same later year outcomes. Where the prior literature finds that much of the contribution of early teachers fades away, we find that the contributions of early-year teachers remain important in later grades. The difference in contributions to eighth-grade outcomes between an effective and ineffective fourth-grade teacher is about half the difference among eighth-grade teachers. The effect on eighth-grade outcomes of replacing a fourth-grade teacher who is below the 5th percentile with a median teacher is about half the underrepresented minority (URM)/non-URM achievement gap. Our results reinforce earlier conclusions in the literature that teachers in all grades are important for student achievement.
Keywords: teacher fade-out, value-added, teacher long-run contributions
Citation: Dan Goldhaber, Zeyu Jin, Richard Startz (2022). How Much Do Early Teachers Matter?. CALDER Working Paper No. 264-0422
You May Also Be Interested In
How Did It Get This Way? Disentangling the Sources of Teacher Quality Gaps Through Agent-Based Modeling
Dan Goldhaber, Matt Kasman, Vanessa Quince, Roddy Theobald, Malcolm Wolff
Taking their First Steps: The Distribution of New Teachers into School and Classroom Contexts and Implications for Teacher Effectiveness and Growth
Paul Bruno, Sarah Rabovsky, Katharine O. Strunk
How Did It Get This Way? Disentangling the Sources of Teacher Quality Gaps Across Two States
Dan Goldhaber, Vanessa Quince, Roddy Theobald