You are here
Equal Treatment as a Means of Evaluating Public School Assignment Mechanisms
A critical element in the sustainability of any public policy is the fair treatment of ‘similar’ individuals. This paper introduces a new dimension of merit to evaluate public school assignment mechanisms based on this notion of horizontal equity. The findings reveal that all of the prominent assignment mechanisms discussed in the literature fail to satisfy this ‘equal treatment’ criterion. I also show that there exists no student-optimal stable mechanism that also satisfies equal treatment, illustrating the tradeoff between constrained efficiency and horizontal equity. These findings surface a serious cause for concern about the public school assignment procedures used in major school districts.
Keywords: School Assignment, Equity , Efficiency
Citation: Umut Özek (2013). Equal Treatment as a Means of Evaluating Public School Assignment Mechanisms. CALDER Working Paper No. 99
You May Also Be Interested In
Choosing Charter Schools in North Carolina: What Do Parents Value?
Helen Ladd, Charles Clotfelter, Mavzuna Turaeva
School Segregation in the Era of Immigration, School Choice, and Color-Blind Jurisprudence – The Case Of North Carolina
Charles Clotfelter, Steven Hemelt, Helen Ladd, Mavzuna Turaeva
The Evolution of Charter School Quality
Patrick Baude, Marcus Casey, Eric Hanushek, Steven Rivkin